Carly Smithson: A Second Chance on American Idol

31 votes
I Like It I Don't Like It
American Idol spoilers were partially correct:

An Irish singer with a professional background wowed judges during this year’s auditions and will be advancing to Hollywood. Her name however, is no longer Carly Hennessy.

Having gotten married since she appeared on Idol’s fifth season under that moniker, this crooner is now known as Carly Smithson. Nevertheless, she was still signed to a recording contract in 2005 and put out an album called “Ultimate High.”

”Everything’s been like right there in front of me — I just haven’t been able to hold on to it,” Smithson said, tearing up, after she was approved for Hollywood, adding that she planned to ”work really hard” to advance in the competion.

Following Smithson’s performance on American Idol season five (during which visa problems led to her disqualification), Paula Abdul told Kristin Dos Santos of E! that the “gorgeous Irish singing sensation” would “blow everyone away.”

Now, she has a second chance to do so. Do you think she deserves one?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zD5_k6BPlFA

ShareThis

anonymous 79 drift82 Published 1/23/08   Message Add to Friends
 

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (40)

  • Why not let's give her a second chance? we are aware of her past experience nobody knew who she was I checked out her video she did six years ago she is damned great. and her auditioned shows her soulful side. Why not? give her a second chance or you guys are into people who suck like William Hung , etc.
    anonymous anonymous 1/23/08 Reply
     
  • but william hung was funny!
    flyaway2high 42 flyaway2high 1/23/08   Message Add to Friends Reply
     
  • isn't this AMERICAN Idol? why is an irish singer on here?
    DusknDawn00 802 DusknDawn00 1/23/08   Message Add to Friends Reply
     
  • Perhaps her 'name change' is because she married a guy with the last name! He went to school with me in Charleston so I'm sure of it. Imagine that. No one is digging on the Australian guy so give her a chance.
    anonymous anonymous 1/24/08 Reply
     
  • Carly smithson is an American citizen and is therefore entled to audition just like every other citizen. If you take out all the black people because they originated in Africa, all the hispanics beause their roots may be Spanish, Mexican, the Australians who came there at 12 years old etc etc, is there any American Indidans in there as they seem to be the true Americans, or did Daniel Boone "the big man" wipe them all out ? The land of the free my arse, all for one and one for all. Give the girl a chance, she carries the passport !
    anonymous anonymous 1/27/08 Reply
     
  • the rules of the show are that you must not have a recording contract - SHE DOESN'T HAVE ONE -
    she has every right! Keep up this publicity - it's all about getting your name out there
    Go Carly, as Paula Abdul said, "you're brilliant"
    anonymous anonymous 1/27/08 Reply
     
  • this whole thing is ridiculous, she doesnt have any recording contract now, and she is an american citizen, so give her a break and let her go on with her life. Personally, I really like her and think she could go far.
    anonymous anonymous 2/9/08 Reply
     
  • Carly has as much right as anyone else to be on the show, she is an american citizen and doesn't have a recording contract. Great publicity!if only a fraction of the 44 million Americans who claim to have Irish roots vote for her she's a definate winner. Hope she goes all the way :)
    anonymous anonymous 2/14/08 Reply
     
  • American Idiot(OPPS)Idol was to find talent that
    "outside" the established music puppy mills.
    These basic raw talents could be "discovered" and given the help and training to really be something to enjoy.
    Now it's all preplanned and scripted with hype all for ratings.
    anonymous anonymous 2/15/08 Reply
     
  • Finally some controversy !

    Why not leave her alone? She seems to be good and we're quite sure we'll enjoy watching her sing on the shows...

    On the other hand, she might take the place of someone who has never had the opportunity (think Josiah)
    anonymous anonymous 2/15/08 Reply
     
  • You know you people are crazy, so she had a contract, shes not the only one this season. Half the people this season have released a cd. Besides, have you forgotten about the plus-sized model winning on Monique’s Fat Chance or David Archuleta’s Star Search win?
    anonymous anonymous 2/16/08 Reply
     
  • Isn't American Idol about finding talent??? I think that everyone forgets this when they are so worried about whether or not someone is American or has had a record contract previously. Carly is good and deserves a chance same as anyone else.
    anonymous anonymous 2/19/08 Reply
     
  • However, Randy WAS VP of MCA Records back in 2001 when she was signed and you mean to tell me that he's forgotten that???????
    anonymous anonymous 2/19/08 Reply
     
  • She's hawt. Let sing.
    anonymous anonymous 2/21/08 Reply
     
  • anonymous anonymous 2/21/08 Reply
     
  • Look around the set (Coca Cola anyone) and see the product placements...and the biggest one is Carly Smithson. If you like being manipulated vote for her...you're all sheep!
    anonymous anonymous 2/21/08 Reply
     
  • I think it is a shame that she is aloud to be in the competion. She had her chance with two albums and she was a flop. She should not be aloud in the competion because she had a contract with Randy Jackson. It's supposed to be for amatuers...she is a professional that flopped... move on Carly.
    anonymous anonymous 2/21/08 Reply
     
  • I think it is a shame that someone spells "allowed" aloud. Pathetic. Learn some English or get a friggin dictionary.
    anonymous anonymous 2/22/08 Reply
     
  • Carly had a chance and blew it. If she couldn't sell an album then, she definately can't sell one now. She should be disqualified for sure!
    anonymous anonymous 2/23/08 Reply
     
  • I think it's a shame that most people who post comments here don't know how to use proper english. I mean, come on guys, you're supposed to be americans righ? and english is your first language, so why don't you buy a friggin' dictionary and learn more english.

    I think carly is Great and fantastic. Who cares if she's had record contracts before? AI is for aspiring singers who can can make it to the hollywood.

    Go carly, you have my votes.!!!.
    anonymous anonymous 2/25/08 Reply
     
  • whats the big deal is is because she is irish give the girl a chance for gods sake stop all the whining!!!!!
    anonymous 5 majella1975 2/25/08   Message Add to Friends Reply
     
  • You all sound funny. Face it, all the good talent is already signed or under 14 years old. Ya Carly sounds ok, but no one in this group blows away the competion. Just so so music.
    anonymous anonymous 2/27/08 Reply
     
  • Everyone keeps saying that she had a record deal, blah, blah, blah. Well so did Chris Daughtry before American Idol. So did a bunch of other contestants. Not all of the contestants are virgins to the music industry.
    anonymous anonymous 2/28/08 Reply
     
  • Carly Smithson is a plant that American idol let through, They realize that Being like Avril Lavinge is popular, The rebel chick you know..
    It would make me sick to my stomach if she won,. She made good money off of the company she was in.. So I guess people like Bobby Brown can go on the show, Defeats the purpose
    anonymous anonymous 2/29/08 Reply
     
  • Carly is beautiful and can sing! That's what this is all about... Not origin or old record deals. Grow up and get over it
    anonymous 5 emilbert 2/29/08   Message Add to Friends Reply
     
  • anonymous anonymous 3/10/08 Reply
     
  • hey carly smithson is the best vocalist so far in this season of american idol. she has an amazing voice and i lve her for that
    anonymous anonymous 3/10/08 Reply
     
  • How does anybody know that Carly is an actual American citizen? Are you just assuming it because she married an American? That just means she can get a permanent visa, not that she's actually taken the citizenship classes and sworn her allegience to America. Has she done that? Can anybody tell me that?
    anonymous anonymous 3/10/08 Reply
     
  • I met Carly Henessy in 1999 when she was working on her album Ultimate High and I have to let you guys know that she was the ultimate bitch to everyone she worked with. She was rude and nothing at all like the ' sweet little Irish girl' that you see on the show. I hope that she gets booted off , she's a nasty piece of work.
    anonymous anonymous 3/11/08 Reply
     
  • carly is talented and has amazing vocals. it is as plain as that
    anonymous anonymous 3/12/08 Reply
     
  • carly is talented and has amazing vocals. it is as plain as that
    anonymous anonymous 3/12/08 Reply
     
  • Carly is brilliant. Who cares if she had a record deal when she was 18. It is sad that people cannot accept her for what she is. "An amazing talent, a tremendous voice, and hard worker.
    anonymous anonymous 3/12/08 Reply
     
  • she had her chance didnt work out move on give someone else a chance, cheating cheating cheating she will not get my vote
    anonymous anonymous 3/19/08 Reply
     
  • Carly is a well-know semen slurper back in the Emerald isle. Many many many many men can attest to the fact tha she sucks.
    anonymous anonymous 3/24/08 Reply
     
  • There is another side to all the lies about her and it's all good. Do your research or remain ignorant. She currently meets ALL Idol rules. She IS undiscovered talent. MCA admittedly blew her first opportunity. Given how AI works and how they finally netted quality talent, she isn't a lock to win but she is my favorite...
    anonymous anonymous 4/1/08 Reply
     
  • Carly Smithson really sucks…. actually they all either suck or are boring as hell to watch. This is the worst American Idol ever. The contestants are all boring… with the possible exception of David Cook, but I gotta admit, sometimes even he gets on my nerves as trying to be a Chris Daughtry clone.

    After watching it last night, I’ve decided no more. The final 6 are putrid and it's just not entertaining to watch at all anymore…..

    Archuleta.... Boring, who wants to listen to 50's music?
    Cook..... Good, but not great
    Castro.... He can be Don Ho's replacement in Hawaii
    Smithson... She just plain SUCKS
    White.... Nanny is boring as hell
    Syesha.... Screams her lyrics, no personality

    Nice run AI, but it is over… you just ain’t got it anymore.
    anonymous anonymous 4/17/08 Reply
     
  • Carly is AWSOME
    anonymous anonymous 4/20/08 Reply
     
  • did carly get a record deal...i heard she did but i dont know if its true or not
    anonymous anonymous 4/23/08 Reply
     
  • last night's elimination proved what i hve believed all along...Idol is a popularity contest. it has nothing to do with whether you can sing or not. Carly was one of the best singers on the show but look what happened. this is exactly like last year with Senjaya. when will people learn???
    anonymous anonymous 4/24/08 Reply
     
  • What is wrong with you people?! Do some research, Kelly Clarkson had a record deal before AI, so did Bo Bice and Taylor Hicks, no one said a thing about them! None of them broke ANY rules, it does not matter if they had a record deal in the past, do some research. I cannot believe she was kicked off, should have been Jason Castro or Brooke.
    anonymous anonymous 4/24/08 Reply