Who's your favorite American Idol, winner or not?

Common America! you have to have something to say about someone up there. I don't remember Chris winning anything! I didn't hear any of Jenifer's hits yet. Kelly started with a bang! The only thing I can remember of Kelly or Jenifer is that they played in one movie each. Kelly can sing and has done a few shows along the way. I like that song Kelly made Called "Walk away" or something. Ruben, He made "I'm Sorry" they played that hit over and over on the radio and that was it of Ruben. We started Improving on that song, it turned into "I'm Sorry I ate all the corn chips...And that grey headed guy, what's his name? Oh Taylor Hicks, wow I saw him in a Ford truck camercial, over and over again, then what? I guess his other hit's as Ford means, "Found on road Dead" because I don't see or hear from him. I could swear he lied about his age anyway he might be as old as Kenny Rodgers. I hate that they haven't gone as far as they have as hard as it was to take the fans through the seasons. We just forget they're here sometimes and that shouldn't be. Sometimes I wonder if they win American Idol as if it was just a test on TV, so we can have something to watch at that time? or did they really want to be "StarS"? After all of that hard work from all of the contestants and winners, and from the fans that voted, We diserve More from each of them. They shouldn't just die out. We should hear more from Clay Akin too We put a lot in that show, they need to put out! Kelly was our hope for that show and our First winner. She should be off the roof right now.....She was my favorate.....Thanks for reading. P.S. If you feel voting for them was a waste of time, then Don't forget to vote for the right person to become President of the United States instead that might make up for our lost. God bless "America" and American Idol.

true true.

true but daughtry is doing REALLY good right now.

Well, I see they left Clay and Carrie off the poll to give Kelly a chance. Pathetic.

Both of them sing circles around that girl, and are good role models.

Clay's run on Broadway was a HUGE success, and his new album will be vocally superior to anything out there.

Carrie is so loved by the country music world, and has grown so much as a singer.

I like Kelly but in the picture she looks a little drunk. lol

I like chris daughtry allot! he may not be cute but hes an amazing singer! i love you chris!

jennifer hudson is the most amazing musician in the world!! i have never heard anything like her before!! i get chills when she belts!!

Clay Aiken should be offered as a choice to vote for.

I loved Blake Lewis.

How did you come up with such a short list, & why didn't you at least have a fill in spot. Plus it would have been more informative, if the list was larger & everyone could pick their top 3 & with ranking points being applied to each position. Hicks & Studdard should not even have been listed. Clay, Doolittle, Bo Bice, etc should be. Thanks anyway ---Tim

OK, where is MY fave, Carrie Underwood?"???????

Ruben is my winner even if he is not in there no more