Who's your favorite American Idol judge?

Poll Results

Who's your favorite American Idol judge?
  • Randy Jackson Pictures: MTV Randy Jackson Presents: America’s Best Dance Crew; Randy Jackson MTV Reality Show
    Randy 15%
  • Paula Abdul Pictures: Paula Abdul Breaks Down During Interview!
    Paula 29%
  • Simon Cowell Pictures: Simon Cowell Planning To Attend Glastonbury Festival
    Simon 56%

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (4)

  • I think that Simon is a good judge because he says what's on his mind. I also like him because I like how he talks. He is a very good judge he tells you how it is, it ain't, and how it's gone be. To me he is only hard on people because he wants them to do their best.
    anonymous 5 Punkin 5/16/08   Message Add to Friends Reply
     
  • simon is so fake!!! he is very rude to people and thinks his own crap does not stink!!!! He thinks he is all that and he is not MAYBE thats why he is still single GEEZ WONDER WHY---HE IS SELFCENTERED AND ONLY LOVES HIMSELF!!!!LOL
    anonymous anonymous 5/18/08 Reply
     
  • I think Simon is the best judge compared with Randy and Paula.He really tells what he wanted to and it's good for the singers also.For me I voted for Simon as BEST american idol judge:)More power to you Simon:)
    anonymous anonymous 5/19/08 Reply
     
  • All Art is a perception and abstract expression from the interactionist. The is difficult to measure perfection. I love Tribal music...because it is so spiritual. Some of us can't tolerate "Country and Western" or "Hilly Billy" sounds. Some Americans could never sit and absorb classical music or Dixie land Jazz. Some only want to be surrounded by "Rap." We all have to learn and to listen closer with respect. Are the sounds sharp? What is the singer's vocal range? Annunciation? and last but not least: The Emotion and Poetry of the peice. For me ,art that makes the world better, is always more meaningful. Simmon is not evaluating objectively...when he is derogitory he is not professional! If it's too difficult for him... He should evaluate the performance as a science, if he can't do it as an artist. Each human on this planet needs to be nurtured and respected. Singing is an ultimate expression of the spirit it heals the individual soul and projects something special magical. We should encourage all human to sing.
    anonymous anonymous 5/22/08 Reply
     
Join The Insider

Got something to say? Express yourself as part of the web's hottest new pop-culture community.
Join Now

Welcome Dotspotters!

Use your Dotspotter username and password, we've made it easy.
Login Now

Already a member?

Login

Find friends on The Insider

User Search

Login using Facebook

People are talking…
Get in on the Action

Chat Now…